User:Morbus Iff/Sojourns and Scholars
This is an incredibly early napkin. Comments to firstname.lastname@example.org please.
Chapter 1: Introduction
Sojourns and Scholars is an attempt at a nearly combat-free conversion of the latest edition of the world's most popular fantasy roleplaying game. It arose out of a desire to play with this latest version, but to do so like the days of yore: where the players and gamemaster together determined the story, not the outcome of mindless skill tests and combats simulated with miniatures and handily-named attack moves. One could say that we're attempting to convert a gamist system back into a narrativist one, but we'd rather just state that we prefer to use the latest rules to play in a world where physical combat barely exists.
This world is Ghyll, "an amazing collaborative improvisational fiction that combines an intoxicating patchouli whiff of fantasy with the reckless driving tanginess of bebop", or so says one now-deleted Internet blog. The worlds (or, more accurately, orthogonalities) of Ghyll originated as an encyclopedia whose creation depended on a small ruleset of forced integration called Lexicon: an RPG.
Players became "cranky, opinionated, prejudiced, and eccentric [scholars] from before scholarly pursuits became professionalized ... Despite the fact that your peers are self-important, narrow-minded dunderheads, they are honest scholars. No matter how strained their interpretations are, their facts are as accurate as historical research can make them ... [You] have to treat its factual content as true! (Though you can argue vociferously with the interpretation and introduce new facts that shade the interpretation.)"
After 18 months and more than 50 players, the wiki used to contain the encyclopedia grew to more than 300 full articles, hundreds of timeline entries and people, maps of the known world, and a healthy sense of erudition. Each entry, no matter how foolish or serious, fit in with factual data previously established. The Encyclopedants, acting as the encyclopedia's gamemasters, spent obscene amounts of time ensuring that flavor, sanity, and plausibility were retained. For some, it became one of their most treasured gaming sessions, even though it was far outside the realm of traditional tabletop roleplaying.
Ghyll is, certainly, a potpourri of ideas, some insatiably silly and others malignantly mixed. With the primary character race being podunkish insectoids, along with singing pachyderms used as morale boosters, Ghyll shares a technology level with traditional fantasy, without being the same old Tolkeinesque or traditional rehash of medieval elements. There are no suits of mail here, no longswords, no halflings or elves. Merely humanoids with a penchant for singing, doggerel, and a need to fit in.
The Core Tenets of Sojourns and Scholars
Sojourns and Scholars differs greatly from the ruleset it purports to work with. Whereas that ruleset advances players through the levels of life by killing hordes of plastic miniatures, Sojourns and Scholars is focused on exploration, discovery, note-taking, and article-writing. Everyone plays as a "fact-finding" (often "fact-inventing") scholar, and your ultimate goal is to be well-known but, more importantly, well-read.
All players are gamemasters
In the Lexicon rules that inspired Sojourns and Scholars, everything written down becomes fact. This is easy, at first, since so few facts exist. As the game continues to be played, and the world begins to take shape (both in locality and in flavor), however, these facts intertwine ever further. Eventually, truth begin to stretch and morph: where one scholar defines something, only to have another twist and expand it to something entirely different. Scholars try to paint facts into corners, for others to devise a way out of. Logic-based "traps" form, family histories become convoluted, plots become thicker, and always, always, a semblance of truth rings out.
This roleplaying game is no different: even though, as a team of scholars exploring and witnessing the same thing, the notes you take and the encyclopedia articles you submit determine the truth of what is known. Ghyll is a game of consensus reality - the more people who believe in what you write cause your words to become real, to become the truth of what is being described. Naturally, other scholars would prefer their truths to be self-evident, and arguments about which truth is most representative of what really occurred replace the physical combat of most tabletop roleplaying games.
Writing, of some sort, is expected of all players.
Players start out as level 1 scholars, unknown, unread, and hopelessly obsessed with making a mark in the world with their version of the truth. Their primary goal in life is to get one of their writings into the Ghyll Encyclopedia, a massive tome that contains all knowledge of the known world. As such, players and their scholars are constantly expected to take notes of what they're seeing and interpreting and then to wrap these notes up into a concise encyclopedia entry for inclusion. The Encyclopedant (the primary game master of a Sojourns and Scholars campaign) decides which entries are accepted, and the players and characters earn experience based on their literary output.
In this way, world creation is shared by both the game master and his players - players must write articles about the world, game masters must choose one to represent truth, and game masters must also abide by this player-written truth.